Some burgers go big on toppings. Some lean into the heat. But when you want something rich, comforting, and crave-worthy without going overboard you go butter.
The Wisconsin Butter Burger at Chicken Coop NY in Baldwin Place is all about that melty magic. With buttery buns, a perfectly smashed patty, and just the right amount of crispiness and flavor, this burger has been making big flavor moves across the Lower Hudson Valley.
If you’ve never had a butter burger before, this one will make you wonder why you waited so long.
What Makes a Butter Burger Different?
It’s not just about slathering on butter for shock value. A real Wisconsin butter burger is all about balance. The buns are buttered and toasted to golden perfection. The burger patties are smashed flat on a hot grill, locking in flavor while creating those crispy caramelized edges. Then the finishing touch of a pat of soft, melty butter is added just before serving, creating a richness that elevates every bite.
At Chicken Coop NY, we’ve taken that classic Midwestern formula and given it the attention it deserves. The result? A burger that’s indulgent without being messy, bold without being overcomplicated.
Melt-in-Your-Mouth Good Not Greasy
Let’s be clear: a butter burger isn’t greasy, it’s rich. There’s a difference.
The smashed patty gives you a crisp texture without dripping fat. The butter adds moisture and flavor, not sogginess. And the toasted buns hold it all together soft enough to bite through, strong enough to support the goods.
Add in your favorite toppings lettuce, tomato, pickles, or keep it clean with just the essentials. Either way, this burger is built to impress.
Want It Your Way? Go For It
Like everything on the Chicken Coop NY menu, the Butter Burger is totally customizable. Want extra butter or cheese? Done. Prefer sauce on the side? We got you.
Pair it with:
- French Fries (small or large) for the classic combo
- Mac & Cheese if you’re craving comfort
- Sweet Potato Fries for a sweet-and-savory balance
Top it off with a bottled drink, and you’ve got yourself a complete meal that satisfies from the first bite to the last.
Big Flavor in a Simple Package
The beauty of the butter burger is in its simplicity. It doesn’t try to do too much. No trendy ingredients or stacked-high gimmicks. Just quality meat, melty butter, crispy sear, and warm, golden buns.
It’s that back-to-basics flavor you didn’t realize you were missing until now.
And in a world full of overbuilt burgers that fall apart by bite two, the butter burger stays grounded. It’s honest food. Comfort food. And at Chicken Coop NY, it’s made fresh and served with pride.
Why It Matters
Sometimes the best meals aren’t the loudest. They’re the ones that feel familiar, satisfying, and just plain right. The Wisconsin Butter Burger is that kind of meal. One that makes you pause, smile, and say, “Yeah… this is what I wanted.”
At Chicken Coop NY, we’re not about overcomplicating flavor. We’re about getting it right. And the butter burger? We nailed it.
Order your Butter Burger now or stop by and find out why this local favorite is melting hearts and
